Her mother's promise and dio's last wishes are intertwined. Not saying she hasn't done some bad things but that Doesn't mean she's off the deep end like her father who did whatever he wanted (even murder). Nice to know somebody out there isn't part of the 98% that believes aya is just fully evil. Wow you did a better job of explaining everything then I did. I'd gladly be Dio (I cant' make the time stop though XD). Maybe that bold guy felt the same character on Aya so decided to help her (to play a role just like himself).ДЄnd.you mentioned that 'It makes them question just who exactly they were playing as the entire time'. By doing this, Aya's able to keep her promise to her mother, her father and Dio at the same time. You can use a knife to kill as well as to save.ДЄbout the Maria part: Maria just can't tell Jean like 'oh, judging by your current condition, you're beyond help, so let me take you to my master and she can kill you later.' I kinda support Arke12917 here, Maria only played a role which called the ferryman who leads the deads to their final destination then let Aya do the rest work. Plus, to be a good doctor, the human anatomy books are great help. The model of books are shared through the game. Anything could be fatal.ДЄbout the red covered book part: there's no evidence showing that the red book on the shelf in her house IS that anatomy archive. Be it a gun, a chainsaw, or even a small branch from the tree.

Just don't let your kid grab anything dangerous around him/her, even out of the game world. I think that dog is kinda special too.ДЄbout the chainsaw part: I don't want to talk too much about this part. To save her dad she only had to search a key within a dog's body.how hard can that be? And, if you check that dog again, the line would be 'fainted', so it's not dead anyway. Aya watched her father doing experiments all through her years. It makes them question just who exactly they were playing as the entire time and I think that's done pretty well here.ДЄbout the rusty key part: for most of people, to chop some meat with blood on the chopping table is much more acceptable than dumping their hands into a pile of garbage in the flusher (You just can't do that, can you?!). I personally like the thought that she herself was no better so I admit I'm kinda biased towards evidence supporting her being psycho, I think it makes the story more meaningful as it really brings a complex issue to the one playing it. Again, I forgot the exact details of that scene, but watch it again with this in mind.Дidn't know they added new endings, pretty interested in what they will reveal. There was also the matter of the comment the girl makes at the ending when she is being examined by Aya, I forgot the exact words but she seems to mention a lady in a carraige with horses driving it told her to come there to seek help, pretty much as soon as she says this they make it a point to make horses outside audible, heavily implying that Maria was the one who tricked the girl to even coming to her house in the first place. Notice how the lessons that are trying to be enforced into Aya are sympathy and compassion for the subjects, yet the entire game the only time she only shows much emotion is when it personally affects her overall welfare or interests. My memory is fuzzy, but I think there was even a point where she showed no interest in some type of book or didn't have any interesting comment on it, but then in part of the area where you could find her fathers books on the human anatomy and other stuff in it she was curiously interested in it.Д®ven in the If route, when the doll asks Blondie what he would do if she ended up doing the same thing her father did, and he plays it off as ''Impossible, she understands the subjects feelings more than others''. I think this is just goes to show how much she is okay with cutting people up and the overall gory nature of what her father does, like hiding dead animals in her drawer, having no qualms swinging around a chainsaw when she was a child(the flashback scene is pretty important imo).ДЄgain, it has been years since I played this game, but the hints were everywhere. Remember the scene where she needs to rinse off a key that was in a filthy toilet before she is okay with using it? This same girl, will then dissect a dog to retrieve a key that it ate and then use that key with no mention of how disgusting it is.

There is a scene that imo is absolutely blatantly describing that Aya is at the very least unsympathetic to others or apathetic. I haven't played this game in awhile but the evidence that Aya is not a good person are all over throughout the game, in fact. Originally posted by cronnoponno:Spoilers:

Mad father remastered